The 'FUCK YOU" kind of Moderator
Member # 3329
ACLU Sues State Police For Arresting Illegals
01:00 AM EST on Tuesday, January 9, 2007
By Karen Lee Ziner
Journal Staff Writer
PROVIDENCE — The Rhode Island Affiliate of the American Civil Liberties Union yesterday filed a federal lawsuit against the state police, alleging racial profiling and violation of the constitutional rights of 14 Guatemalan nationals during a July traffic stop that led to their detention by immigration officials.
Steven Brown, director of the Rhode Island affiliate, yesterday noted the unusual nature of the lawsuit filed by ACLU volunteer attorney V. Edward Formisano.
“It’s very rare for individuals like these plaintiffs to be willing to step forward and challenge questionable police practices that they’ve been subject to,” said Brown.
“The citizenship status of the plaintiffs is really irrelevant to this lawsuit. These were individuals who were in a van that was stopped for a minor traffic violation. The question is whether police have a right to detain individuals for no other reason than the way they look …”
Said Brown, “The law generally prohibits racial profiling on the highways. It prohibits stopping or searching vehicles based on the person’s race or ethnicity, all of which we think were present in this case. It also specifically bars police officers from detaining individuals in cars longer than necessary to address the initial traffic violation. From our perspective, that restriction was clearly violated in this case.”
The lawsuit names the State of Rhode Island, the state police, state police Supt. Steven M. Pare and Trooper Thomas Chabot individually; and a “Jane Doe” state trooper whose identity the ACLU was unable to establish.
State police spokesman Maj. Steven G. O’Donnell said yesterday, “We respect the ACLU’s right to file any lawsuit but we have reviewed this matter at length and continue to support Trooper Chabot’s actions. We also respect the court process and we’ll wait and see how the court rules” before making any comment.
The allegations stem from a traffic stop by Chabot early on July 11 on Route 95 in Richmond.
According to the lawsuit, Chabot pulled over a van operated by Carlos A. Tamup because Tamup had failed to use his turn signal when changing lanes.
The lawsuit alleges that Chabot first confirmed that Tamup’s license and registration were valid and that he had no criminal record.
“Chabot nonetheless proceeded to open the doors of the vehicle, and by utilizing Tamup as a translator, requested all the passengers to also provide identification,” according to an ACLU synopsis of the case. When some failed to do so, Chabot then asked them to produce documents “demonstrating their U.S. citizenship.”
When none of the 14 were able to do so, Chabot advised them that they would all be escorted to the federal Office of Immigration and Customs Enforcement in Providence.
Then, the lawsuit states, Chabot instructed Tamup, the driver, that he was responsible for the vehicle’s passengers, and that if any passenger attempted to escape from the van en route to Providence, that passenger would be “shot.”
Chabot and the trooper identified only as “Jane Doe,” then escorted the group to the Providence ICE office.
Formisano, the ACLU lawyer, is seeking a declaratory judgment that the defendants violated the constitutional rights of the driver and his passengers, and demands punitive and compensatory damages on behalf of the 11 plaintiffs. Besides Tamup, the plaintiffs are: Astrid G. Estrada, Wendy M. Estrada, Guilfredo E. Munoz, Jose A. Aquino, Cruz F. Rivera, Jose Burgos, Abelino M. Urizar, Israel Tebalan, Rolando Noriega, Boris R. Cruz, and Elsa Hernandez Villavicencio, all of Providence.
The lawsuit argues that the actions by the state police “violated the state’s Racial Profiling Prevention Act, as well as the driver’s and passengers’ constitutional rights to be free from discrimination and from unreasonable searches and seizures.”
The suit argues that the defendants “knew or should have known that the search, seizure and detention of the plaintiffs were without reasonable or probable cause, and were therefore unlawful under the circumstances.”
The lawsuit also steps into the heart of a national controversy over whether local police should be involved in enforcement of federal immigration laws.
Brown said, “To their credit, many police departments across the country have rejected the opportunity to enforce those laws for a number of reasons. I think first they recognize they don’t have the expertise with these laws … also, that doing so undermines trust in the communities that they serve. People in immigrant communities are going to think twice before they contact police if they’ve been victims of a crime, if they think they’ll be the ones who end up on trial.”
The van stop also rattled Rhode Island civil rights advocates, who during a public forum this summer and a subsequent news conference, criticized state police Superintendent Pare’s response to the incident. Pare ordered an internal review after the ACLU filed a complaint. That investigation cleared Chabot; Pare stated that Chabot acted “professionally and appropriately,” and denied racial profiling by the trooper.
The state police response to the first complaint “expressed complete satisfaction with the way the stop and detention occurred, which led to this lawsuit,” said Brown. __________________
-------------------- FUCK OBAMA AND ALL LIBERAL ASSWIPES. Posts: 2524 | From: USA | Registered: Jun 2006
| IP: Logged
Does anyone know the meaning of the word ILLEGAL ??????????? Fuckers have no rights
-------------------- "Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both" ~ Benjamin Franklin Posts: 718 | From: essex ny | Registered: Jan 2006
| IP: Logged
In the State of Texas it is illegal for a State Peace Officer to arrest Wet Backs. This was the result of a law suit and Federal Court Ruling in the early 1980s. Prior to that I arrested numerous Wets, even Wets from Germany. Arrest them, put the in jail, and release them to the Border Patrol when they came to pick them up. Marshal Service paid us $27.00 a day for a Federal Prisoner.
I told the US Attorney's Office that if they didn't want us arresting Wets, we wouldn't arrest any one wanted on Federal Warrants or Committing Federal Crimes such as Robbery of A Federal Lending Instutition such as bank, unless they are covered under State Law (which 99.9% are) but the US Attorney didn't know it. Got in a real huff about a smartassed Municipal Police Chief.
-------------------- From this day to the ending of the world we in it shall be remembered. We lucky few, we band of brothers. For he who today sheds his blood with me shall be my brother. CURRAHEE
Graduate: University of South Vietnam School of Jungle Warfare Posts: 6016 | From: Texas | Registered: Oct 2000
| IP: Logged
more PC bull shit. they are no longer illegal aliens they are undocumented immigrants. what the hell does that mean they just lost something
Posts: 1628 | From: detroit michigan. | Registered: Apr 2001
| IP: Logged
quote:Originally posted by Jungle Work: Got in a real huff about a smartassed Municipal Police Chief.
I'm sure that wasn't the only huff n' puff you got over the years.
I lost a few days after going off on an INS supervisor.when they refused for the several dozenth (is that a word?? ) time to come out and get someone we popped for a Minor charge.. Apparently they heard me on the second floor when i yelled into the phone "WHAT THE FUCK DO you people Do..you Certainly Dont do your fucking jobs..which I was under the impression was to GED RID OF THESE FUCKING ILLEGALS..." it was worth losing 2 days pay..i wouldnt give them the satisfaction of letting them take 2 vacation days....besides my "suspension" just happeend to be a holiday weekend...fuck em.
Posts: 155 | From: Northern NJ | Registered: Apr 2006
| IP: Logged
quote:Originally posted by PATRIOT48071: more PC bull shit. they are no longer illegal aliens they are undocumented immigrants. what the hell does that mean they just lost something
Calling illegal combatants prisoners of war, or calling illegal aliens undocumented immigrants is like calling a burglar an uninvited house guest.
-------------------- Regards, Bill _ _______________________________ _ I could eat a can of alphabet soup and shit a better argument than that. Posts: 5508 | From: East central Indiana | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged
All contributions become the property of HardCoreTalk.com The Opinions, Views and Comments expressed by the members of this forum and website are their own and do not necessarily state or reflect those of HardCoreTalk.com or any of it's agents. HardCoreTalk.com does not guarantee the accuracy, integrity or quality of these messages and opinions, and does not perform an independent investigation to verify their truth or accuracy. All posted messages are the sole responsibility of the person from which such post originated. HardCoreTalk.com assumes no liability in any way for the content of any posted message or opinion, including, but not limited to, any errors or omissions in any posted message
FAIR USE NOTICE
This board contains copyrighted material, which is reproduced under the Fair Use Provision of Title 17, U.S.C. Section 107, and is posted for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. This material is posted without profit for the benefit of those who, by accessing this site, are expressing a prior interest in this information for research and educational purposes.
This discussion board is strictly operated as a non profit venture and is for the express purpose of educating and informing our members and visitors.